Why Is There A COVID Vaccine Mandate For Students?

Authored by Margaret Anna Alice by job of 'Via The Attempting Glass’ Substack,

Letter to the Stanford Day-to-day: Why Is There a COVID Vaccine Mandate for College students?

“Now to not know is deplorable. Now to not want to know is worse.”

—African proverb

I will’t resolve out why Stanford is mandating the COVID vaccine for college college students.

1. Is it to protect school college students from the virus, hospitalization, or demise?

2. Is it to protect them from diversified school college students?

3. Is it to protect the Stanford workforce members from the school college students?

If it’s to protect the school college students from catching COVID, that doesn’t beget sense as a result of the CDC says it “now not differentiate[s] in preserving with a selected particular person’s vaccination function as a result of leap ahead infections happen.”

The CDC additionally acknowledges pure immunity, noting that “folks who get had COVID-19 however are now not vaccinated get some stage of safety in opposition to extreme sickness from their outdated an infection.”

It seems to be like Stanford didn’t rating the memo as a result of Maxwell Meyer—a double-jabbed, COVID-recovered alum who modified into as soon as almost prohibited from graduating for choosing now not to attain boosted—modified into as soon as prompt by an administrator that the booster mandate is “now not predicated on historic earlier of an infection or bodily house.”

Regardless of residing 2,000 miles a methods from campus and now not being enrolled in coursework for his final time size, Maxwell modified into as soon as prompt Stanford modified into as soon as “uniformly enforc[ing]” the mandate “irrespective of pupil house.” Does that sound like a rational protection?

Thankfully, a particular administrator intervened and granted Maxwell an exemption, however few Stanford school college students are so fortunate. Almost everybody else merely follows the foundations with out realizing they’ve volunteered for vaccine roulette.

A Cleveland Sanatorium leer of the bivalent vaccines shiny 51,011 contributors discovered the danger of getting COVID-19 elevated “with the necessity of vaccine doses beforehand purchased”—exceptional to the authors’ shock.

That they had been stumped as to why “folks that selected now not to use the CDC’s methods about final up so far with COVID-19 vaccination” had a decrease danger of catching COVID than “folks that purchased a elevated want of prior vaccine doses.”

So if the vaccines don’t retain you from getting COVID, perchance they on the very least defend you from hospitalization?

That doesn’t wash, each, as a result of in preserving with knowledge from the Coronavirus Sickness 2019 (COVID-19)-Linked Hospitalization Surveillance Group (COVID-NET), hospitalization charges for 18–64-One year-olds get elevated 11 p.c as a result of the vaccine rollout. Worse, childhood underneath 18 get suffered a stunning 74 p.c spike in hospitalizations.

An observational leer performed at Germany’s Faculty Medical establishment Wuerzburg discovered:

“The amble of detrimental reactions for the 2nd booster dose modified into as soon as tremendously elevated amongst contributors receiving the bivalent 84.6% (95% CI 70.3%–92.8%; 33/39) when put subsequent to the monovalent 51.4% (95% CI 35.9–66.6%; 19/37) vaccine (p=0.0028). Moreover, there modified into as soon as a sample in route of an elevated value of incapability to work and consumption of PRN remedy following bivalent vaccination.”

A contemporary paper printed in Science titled Class Swap In opposition to Non-Inflammatory, Spike-Order IgG4 Antibodies after Repeated SARS-CoV-2 mRNA Vaccination even has Eric Topol involved:

Leisurely after mRNA Covid vaccines, or with booster or leap ahead infections, there’s a shift to IgG4 antibodies, now not thought of with adenovirus vector vaccines. The scientific significance is rarely any longer knownhttps://t.co/5thLxRwemm @SciImmunology @UniFAU pic.twitter.com/YozSLVjVLd

— Eric Topol (@EricTopol) December 22, 2022

Should you don’t know what which methodology, Dr. Syed Haider spells it out in this tweet. He explains that the pictures “put collectively your immune machine to disregard the allergen by repeated publicity,” the pause end result being that “Your immune machine is shifted to see the virus as a harmless allergen” and the “virus runs amok.”

— Dr. Syed Haider (@DrSyedHaider) December 28, 2022

Viral immunologist and computational virologist Dr. Jessica Rose breaks down the critical implications—together with most cancers, deadly fibrosis, and organ destruction—of these findings.

Effectively, then does the vaccine on the very least stop of us from demise of COVID?

Nope. Mainly based mostly solely on the Washington Put up, “Vaccinated of us now beget up a majority of COVID deaths.”

At Senator Ron Johnson’s December 7, 2022, roundtable dialogue on COVID-19 Vaccines, former number-one–ranked Wall Aspect freeway insurance coverage protection analyst Josh Stirling reported that, in preserving with UK govt knowledge:

“The of us within the UK who took the vaccine get a 26% elevated mortality value. The these which can be underneath the age of fifty who took the vaccine now get a 49% elevated mortality value.”

Bought by a Freedom of Data Act (FOIA) quiz to KBV (the affiliation representing physicians who purchase insurance coverage protection in Germany), “the most important dataset of the pandemic” shows fatalities beginning to spike in 2021.

Data analyst Tom Lausen assessed the ICD-10 sickness codes on this dataset, and the findings are startling. His presentation includes the next chart documenting fatalities per quarter from 2016 to 2022:

This parallels the skyrocketing fatality charges thought of in VAERS:

The vaccinated most ceaselessly generally tend to contract, develop to be hospitalized from, and die of COVID. If the vaccine fails on all of these counts, does it on the very least stop its transmission to diversified school college students and workforce members?

The gross resolution is rarely any since we already understand it doesn’t stop you from getting COVID, however this CDC leer drives the extent dwelling, displaying that throughout a COVID outbreak in Barnstable County, Massachusetts, “three quarters (346; 74%) of instances happened in totally vaccinated folks.”

Presumably Stanford can expose us why they really feel the mandate is most well-known. Their booster requirement reads:

“Why does Stanford get a pupil booster shot requirement? Our booster requirement is meant to fortify sustained immunity in opposition to COVID-19 and is per the recommendation of county and federal public neatly being leaders. Booster pictures fortify immunity, offering extra safety to folks and reducing the totally different of being hospitalized for COVID. Apart from to, booster pictures stop an infection in lots of folks, thereby slowing the unfold of the virus. A carefully boosted campus workforce reduces the totally different of present disruptions that might maybe moreover impression the pupil journey, specifically by methodology of in-particular particular person lessons and actions and congregate housing.”

The declare that “booster pictures fortify immunity” hyperlinks to a January 2022 Modern York Occasions article. It seems to be like Stanford has failed to guard up with the science as a result of the very supply they cite as authoritative is now reporting, “The extra contemporary variants, often known as BQ.1 and BQ.1.1, are spreading snappily, and boosters appear to fabricate restricted to stop infections with these viruses.”

Speaking of now not preserving up, that equivalent article says the contemporary bivalent boosters goal “the standard model of the coronavirus and the Omicron variants circulating earlier this One year, BA.4 and BA.5.”

It then goes on to cite Head of Beth Israel Deaconess’s Coronary heart for Virology & Vaccine Examine Dan Barouch, who says, “It’s now not going that any of the vaccines or boosters, it doesn’t matter what variety of you rating, will current tall and sustained safety in opposition to acquisition of an infection.”

In diversified phrases, Stanford’s rationale for requiring the boosters is broken-down in preserving with the authority they cite of their justification.

If Stanford is genuinely involved about “reduc[ing] the totally different of present disruptions that might maybe moreover impression the pupil journey,” then it is going to most definitely soundless now not handiest stop mandating the vaccine however listing in opposition to it.

Some worldwide areas get suspended or immediate in opposition to COVID pictures for youthful populations because of the noteworthy dangers of detrimental occasions harking back to pulmonary embolism and myocarditis—from Denmark (underneath 50) to Norway (underneath 45) to Australia (underneath 50) to the United Kingdom (seasonal boosters for underneath 50).

The Danish Effectively being Authority explains why of us underneath 50 are “now not to be re-vaccinated”:

“Other people feeble underneath 50 are most ceaselessly now not at specifically elevated danger of changing into severely sick from covid-19. Apart from to, youthful of us feeble underneath 50 are neatly top-notch in opposition to changing into severely sick from covid-19, as a in fact easy want of them get already been vaccinated and get beforehand been contaminated with covid-19, and there is resulting from this upright immunity amongst this fragment of the inhabitants.”

Right here’s what a Norwegian physician and neatly being legit needed to declare:

“Specifically the youngest need to soundless take into accout functionality facet leads to opposition to some great benefits of taking this dose.”
—Ingrid Bjerring, Chief Physician at Lier Municipality

“We did now not collect ample proof to counsel that this fragment of the inhabitants [younger age bracket] need to soundless take a model contemporary dose now.… Every vaccine comes with the danger for facet outcomes. Is it then responsible to current this, in spite of everything of us know that the precise specific particular person neatly being assist of a booster probably is low?”
—Are Stuwitz Berg, Division Director on the Norwegian Institute of Public Effectively being

A contemporary Nordic cohort leer of 8.9 million contributors helps these issues, discovering an almost 9-fold lengthen in myocarditis amongst males feeble 12–39 inside 28 days of receiving the Moderna COVID-19 booster over folks that stopped after two doses.

This mirrors my get findings that myocarditis charges are up 10 cases amongst the vaccinated in preserving with a public healthcare worker search.

Coauthored by MIT professor and danger administration skilled Retsef Levi, the Nature article Elevated Emergency Cardiovascular Occasions Amongst Beneath-40 Inhabitants in Israel All the most effective association through Vaccine Rollout and Third COVID-19 Wave reveals a 25 p.c lengthen in cardiac emergency requires 16–39-One year-olds from January to May additionally 2021 as when put subsequent with the outdated two years.

The paper cites a leer by Israel’s Ministry of Effectively being that “assesses the danger of myocarditis after receiving the 2nd vaccine dose to be between 1 in 3000 to 1 in 6000 in males of age 16–24 and 1 in 120,000 in males underneath 30.”

A Thai leer printed in Tropical Treatment and Infectious Sickness discovered cardiovascular manifestations in 29.24 p.c of the adolescent cohort—together with myopericarditis and tachycardia.

Even Dr. Leana Wen, previously an aggressive promoter of the COVID vaccine, admitted in a contemporary Washington Put up op-ed:

“[W]e need to be upfront that on the subject of each intervention has some danger, and the coronavirus vaccine is rarely any diversified. A really exceptional danger is myocarditis, an irritation of the center muscle, which is commonest in younger males. The CDC cites a value of 39 myocarditis instances per 1 million 2nd doses given in males 18 to 24. A chunk evaluation discovered a exceptional elevated value; a easy Canadian database reported that amongst males ages 18 to 29 who purchased the 2nd dose of the Moderna vaccine, the value of myocarditis modified into as soon as 22 for each 100,000 doses.”

All the most effective association through the sector, noteworthy physicians, scientists, politicians, and professors are asking pointed questions about illogical mandates; the security and efficacy of the vaccines; and the dangers posed by the mRNA experience, spike protein, and lipid nanoparticles—together with in the UK, Japan, Australia, Europe, and the US.

Beforehand pro-vaxx cardiologists harking back to Dr. Aseem Malhotra, Dr. Dean Patterson, and Dr. Ross Walker are all asserting the COVID vaccines needs to be straight stopped because of the a lot of lengthen in cardiac illnesses, detrimental occasions, and further mortality seen since their rollout, noting that, “until confirmed in any other case, these vaccines are now not loyal.”

— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) December 18, 2022

@DrAseemMalhotra @DrJBhattacharya @JohnBoweActor @PierreKory pic.twitter.com/lw7jdtzNl4

— Dr Dean Patterson (@mottomeneki) December 10, 2022

President of the World Society for Vascular Surgical scheme Serif Sultan and Promoting advisor Surgeon Ahmad Malik are additionally worrying that we #StopTheShotsNow.

— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) December 16, 2022

And now, perchance most notably, Dr. John Campbell has carried out a 180-stage flip on his outdated place of abode and is asserting it’s time to stay the mass vaccination program “because of the hazards linked with the vaccines”:

A Rasmussen poll printed on December 7, 2022, discovered 7 p.c of vaccinated respondents get suffered most well-known facet outcomes—a share that echoes the 7.7 p.c of V-Glorious clients who sought sanatorium remedy as neatly as my get polling knowledge.

Add the 34 p.c who reported experiencing minor facet outcomes, and it’s probably you will moreover merely get gotten almost 72 million adults who’ve been hit with facet outcomes from the vaccine.

Rasmussen Head Pollster Mark Mitchell explains:

“With 7% having a most well-known facet manufacture, which methodology over 12 million adults within the US get skilled a self-described most well-known facet manufacture that they attribute to the COVID-19 vaccine. That’s over 11 cases the reported COVID demise numbers. And in addition current that someone who might maybe most definitely moreover merely get died from the vaccine clearly can’t expose us that within the poll.”

Mainly based mostly solely on British Medical Journal Senior Editor Dr. Peter Doshi, Pfizer’s and Moderna’s get trial knowledge discovered 1 in 800 vaccinated of us skilled critical detrimental occasions:

“The Pfizer and Moderna trials are each displaying a decided imprint of elevated danger of significant detrimental occasions amongst the vaccinated.…

“The trial knowledge are indicating that we’re seeing about an elevated danger of these critical detrimental occasions of spherical 1 in 800 of us vaccinated.… That may be a methods, exceptional further customary than what you see for diversified vaccines, the place the reported charges are within the fluctuate of 1 or 2 per million vaccinees. In these trials, we’re seeing 1 in each 800. And proper here is a value that in earlier years has had vaccines taken off the market.…

“We’re speaking about randomized trials … which might maybe be extensively even handed the very ideally superior-quality proof, and we’re speaking in regards to the trials that had been submitted by Pfizer and Moderna that supported the regulators’ authorization.”

Dr Peter Doshi senior editor of the BMJ wishes to know why we get now not already #StoptheShots when 1 in 800 are severely harmed, but outdated vaccines had been suspended for harming 'handiest’ 1 in 100’000.
Beats me too! pic.twitter.com/llT4JwL5WQ

— Porridge2022 (@porridge2022) December 16, 2022

And proper here is the equivalent Pfizer knowledge the FDA tried to guard hidden from the ultimate public for 75 years.

Nothing to see proper right here … excluding 1,223 deaths, 158,000 detrimental occasions, and 1,291 facet outcomes reported within the first 90 days in preserving with the 5.3.6 Cumulative Prognosis of Put up-Authorization Dangerous Match Experiences—and folks numbers are probably underreported by a narrate of on the very least 10 (my conservative calculations exhibit an underreporting narrate (URF) of 41 for VAERS).

Stanford is asking school college students to danger a 1 in 800 likelihood of significant detrimental occasions—which methodology the roughly occasions that may land you within the scientific establishment, disable you, and extinguish you. And for what?

Somebody who’s conscious of straightforward strategies to maintain a cost-help prognosis can see proper here is all value and nil assist.

Stanford’s get Dr. John Ioannidis—professor of remedy, epidemiology & inhabitants neatly being, statistics, and biomedical knowledge science—demonstrated that school school college students are at a shut to-zero danger of demise from COVID-19 in his “Age-Stratified An an infection Fatality Cost of COVID-19 within the Non-Aged Inhabitants.”

Thought to be one in every of many six most-cited scientists on the earth, Ioannidis discovered the median IFR modified into as soon as 0.0003 p.c for these underneath 20 and 0.002 p.c for twenty-somethings, concluding the fatalities “are decrease than pre-pandemic years when handiest the youthful age strata are even handed” and that “the IFR in non-elderly folks modified into as soon as exceptional decrease than beforehand notion.”

And but Ioannidis’s employer is mandating an experimental product with extensively documented dangers of extreme harm.

What if a Stanford pupil dies and the coroner determines it modified into as soon as resulted in by the vaccine? That happened of dwelling with George Watts Jr., a 24-One year-venerable school pupil whose motive within the serve of demise Chief Deputy Coroner Timothy Cahill Jr. attributed to “COVID-19 vaccine-connected myocarditis.” Cahill says, “The vaccine resulted within the guts to cross into failure.”

Notorious for mandating a booster now not but examined on people (elegant like Stanford), Ontario’s Western Faculty dropped its mandate on November 29, 2022, stating:

“We’re revoking our vaccination protection and might maybe most definitely merely now not require school college students, employees, and firm to be vaccinated to reach serve to campus.”

That changed into as soon as the equivalent day this text reported that 21-One year-venerable Western Faculty pupil and TikTok influencer Megha Thakur “ and handed away” on November 24.

The timing is attention-grabbing, don’t you’ve gotten religion you studied? I’m incredible it’s elegant a coincidence—even if this Scientific Examine in Cardiology paper decided vaccine-resulted in myocardial irritation modified into as soon as the motive within the serve of demise in “5 folks who get died inside seven days following anti-SARS-CoV-2-vaccination.” In that prognosis, the authors “place the histological phenotype of deadly vaccination-connected myocarditis.”

Coincidences nonetheless, Stanford might maybe most definitely moreover merely want to revoke the mandate prior to one factor else like that occurs to with out a doubt one in every of its school college students … if it hasn’t already.

And if that’s now not incentive ample, Stanford need to soundless take into accout the lawful ramifications of mandating an experimental product. As this JAMA article warns:

“Mandating COVID-19 vaccines underneath an EUA is legally and ethically problematic. The act authorizing the FDA to relate EUAs requires the secretary of the Division of Effectively being and Human Firms and merchandise (HHS) to specify whether or not folks might maybe most definitely moreover merely refuse the vaccine and the penalties for refusal. Vaccine mandates are unjustified as a result of an EUA requires a lot much less security and efficacy knowledge than plump Biologics License Utility (BLA) approval.”

Dr. Naomi Wolf delivered an impassioned speech to her alma mater, Yale, by which she often known as their booster mandate “a critical crime. It’s deeply illegal. Undoubtedly, it violates Title IX.” She explains:

“Title IX commits the college to now not discriminate on the premise of intercourse or gender in getting an equal coaching.… I oversee a mission by which 3,500 consultants consider the Pfizer paperwork launched underneath court docket docket dispute by a lawsuit. In that narrative, there’s catastrophic harm to girls folks! And specifically to younger ladies folks! And specifically to their reproductive neatly being.… 72% of these with detrimental occasions within the Pfizer paperwork are ladies folks!”

Assorted universities are at present going through complaints for mandating the COVID vaccine in violation of articulate legal guidelines, together with one in opposition to Ohio Faculty, Faculty of Cincinnati, Bowling Inexperienced Sing Faculty, and Miami Faculty of Ohio.

Let’s recap.

Nice proof proves the vaccines FAIL to:

• stop transmission

• stop contraction of COVID

• decrease hospitalization charges

• decrease mortality

By the equivalent token, this proof shows the vaccines are ASSOCIATED with:

• heightened transmission phases

• elevated prospects of catching COVID

• elevated hospitalization charges

• elevated further mortality

• disproportionate accidents to girls folks

Why is Stanford mandating these unsafe and ineffective merchandise, as soon as extra?

If logic, see-reviewed be taught, and lawful issues harking back to the violation of Title IX don’t persuade Stanford to rescind the mandate, then what about its acknowledged ethical dedication to upholding its Code of Habits?

BMJ’s Journal of Medical Ethics trustworthy now not too way back printed COVID-19 Vaccine Boosters for Younger Adults: A Ache Attend Evaluation and Moral Prognosis of Mandate Insurance policies at Universities. On this paper, neatly-known researchers from Harvard, Oxford, Johns Hopkins, and UC San Francisco (amongst diversified establishments) distinctive 5 causes college mandates are unethical.

They argue that the vaccines:

“(1) are now not in preserving with an up so far (Omicron period) stratified risk-help consider for this age workforce; (2) might maybe most definitely moreover merely give up in a accumulate harm to wholesome younger adults; (3) are now not proportionate: anticipated harms are now not outweighed by public neatly being benefits given modest and transient effectiveness of vaccines in opposition to transmission; (4) violate the reciprocity principle as a result of critical vaccine-connected harms are now not reliably compensated because of gaps in vaccine harm schemes; and (5) might maybe most definitely moreover merely give up in wider social harms.” (emphases mine proper right here and under)

They calculate that:

“To stop one COVID-19 hospitalisation over a 6-month size, we estimate that 31,207–42,836 younger adults feeble 18–29 years have to amass a Third mRNA vaccine.”

The authors attain that:

“college COVID-19 vaccine mandates are inclined to intention accumulate anticipated harms to younger wholesome adults—for each hospitalisation averted we estimate roughly 18.5 SAEs and 1,430–4,626 disruptions of on daily foundation actions.… these extreme infringements of specific specific particular person liberty and human rights are ethically unjustifiable.”

This builds on a beforehand printed BMJ World Effectively being article by a few of the equivalent authors titled, “The Unintended Penalties of COVID-19 Vaccine Protection: Why Mandates, Passports, and Restrictions May additionally Construct off Extra Smash Than Gorgeous.”

On this paper, the authors contend that COVID-19 vaccine mandates “get unintended terrifying penalties and might maybe most definitely merely now not be ethical, scientifically justified, and environment friendly” and “might maybe most definitely moreover merely show to be each counterproductive and unfavorable to public neatly being.”

Over the route of historic earlier, numerous merchandise as soon as thought to be loyal—from DDT to cigarettes to thalidomide for pregnant ladies folks to Vioxx—had been at last discovered to be unhealthy and even deadly. Guilty governments, firms, and corporations pull these merchandise from the market when the scientific knowledge proves harm—and establishments that care about their workforce members with out a doubt don’t mandate these merchandise when proof of danger turns into apparent, as is the case now for the experimental COVID vaccines.

Mahatma Gandhi as soon as acknowledged:

“An error wouldn’t develop to be reality by motive of multiplied propagation, nor does reality develop to be error as a result of no person sees it. Actuality stands, though there be no public fortify. It’s self-sustained.”

Actually obvious to someone who’s prepared to get a study.

Will Stanford stop following the propaganda and open following the science—the true science and now not the politicized science?

Will it come up for the lives and neatly being of its school college students—or will it wait until tragedy strikes one different George Watts Jr. or Megha Thakur?

That may be a historic totally different for Stanford to show its allegiance to of us, scientific knowledge, and critical notion over pharmaceutical donors, political pressures, and conformist pondering.

The stakes might maybe most definitely now not be elevated.

* * *

For 16.4 cents/day (annual) or 19.7 cents/day (month-to-month), it’s probably you will most definitely assist Margaret try in opposition to tyranny whereas participating in entry to prime value narrate materials like Memes by Themes, “rolling” interviews, podcasts, Within the serve of the Scenes, and diversified bonus narrate materials: